|Year : 2007 | Volume
| Issue : 9 | Page : 535-544
How the findings of national family health survey-3 can act as a trigger for improving the status of anemic mothers and undernourished children in India: A review
Chandrakant Lahariya1, Jyoti Khandekar2
1 Department of Community Medicine, Gajara Raja Medical College, Gwalior; Department of Community Medicine, Lady Hardinge Medical College, New Delhi, India
2 Department of Community Medicine, Lady Hardinge Medical College, New Delhi, India
J-395, Darpan Colony, Thatipur, Gwalior - 474011
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
The national family health survey-3 (NFHS-3) reports of declining fertility rate while increasing prevalence of anemia in women and children, since NFHS-2 in 1998-99. The proportion of anemic, stunted and wasted children has also increased since the previous two rounds. NFHS trends show that the status of mother's and child's health indicators is continuing to deteriorate in spite of the many government-run targeted programs, e.g., integrated child development scheme (ICDS), Midday meal program. The only good sign in the findings is the favorable trend in fertility indicators and infant mortality rate.
A review of the findings of NFHS surveys, the current government policies and programs targeted upon the improving of health status of women and children in India and of the published scientific literature was conducted. The aim of the review was to understand the health situation of women and children in India and to suggest measures to bring about positive changes in the health status of this population. The analysis suggests that the findings of these successive surveys are not being utilized for the necessary corrective measures. The authors argue that although the NFHS is a useful exercise, in the wake of decentralized planning, the country needs more detailed data focusing on the districts. Synchronization of the ICDS and national rural health mission (NRHM), along with entrusting the responsibility of conducting NFHS to the planning commission, is the other possible solution to tackle the problems of rising anemia and malnutrition in the country.
Keywords: Anemia, immunization, India, national family health survey, nutrition
|How to cite this article:|
Lahariya C, Khandekar J. How the findings of national family health survey-3 can act as a trigger for improving the status of anemic mothers and undernourished children in India: A review. Indian J Med Sci 2007;61:535-44
|How to cite this URL:|
Lahariya C, Khandekar J. How the findings of national family health survey-3 can act as a trigger for improving the status of anemic mothers and undernourished children in India: A review. Indian J Med Sci [serial online] 2007 [cited 2015 May 29];61:535-44. Available from: http://www.indianjmedsci.org/text.asp?2007/61/9/535/34525
The last few years have generated a demand for strong information system for proper planning in the field of health. The most essential information, to start with, is the baseline data on health indicators, for carrying out monitoring and evaluation in various programs and activities. For a long time after independence, evaluation had only limited focus and no separate resources were made available for collection of information on the health status of the population. The need for countrywide health information was felt strongly in the early nineties, and the first national family health survey (NFHS) was conducted in 1992-93. 
The NFHS, is one of the largest household surveys conducted in India. The NFHS aims to help the planners and policy makers in the process of informed decision making, besides keeping a track of the health trends in the country. The first survey (NFHS-1) was conducted in 1992-93, followed by second survey (NFHS-2) in 1998-99.  NFHS-3 is the latest in this series.
The preliminary results from NFHS-3 show decline in fertility rate and infant mortality rate (IMR) but rising prevalence of anemia in women and children and almost static and high prevalence of malnutrition in children aged less than 3 years, since NFHS-2. The indicators of health-seeking behavior also show negative trends.
This paper is based upon the secondary analysis of NFHS-3 data released by International Institute of Population Sciences (IIPS), India, and analyzes the findings of this NFHS-3 in the perspective of the health scenario in India. This review was conducted with the aims of understanding the health situation of the mothers and children in India and suggesting measures to bring about positive changes in their health status.
| ¤ How This Review was Conducted|| |
Keeping in mind the aims of this review, all the published reports of NFHS-1 and NFHS-2 were studied, along with the study of the preliminary reports of the current round of the NFHS. The main focus was on the trends of the health indicators since the NFHS-1. The critical commentaries, scientific publications and other reports on NFHS were also collected and studied. PubMed search engine, libraries and internet resources were used for this data collection. A detailed information search on the various government policies and programs targeted upon improving the health status of women and children was carried out. This paper is based upon the trend analysis of NFHS findings, in the background of various health programs being run in the country.
| ¤ Methodology of NFHS -3|| |
The planning of NFHS-3 had started in February 2005 and the field work was done from December 2005 to August 2006, covering all 28 states and Delhi. It was conducted under the guidance of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MOHFW), with International Institute of Population Sciences, Mumbai, as nodal agency. The ORC Macro, USA, provides technical assistance, with funding from five international (USAID, DFID, UNFPA, UNICEF, Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation) and two national agencies (NARI and NACO), besides partial funding by the Government of India.
The objectives of the NFHS-3 are twofold - firstly, to provide essential data on health and family welfare needed by Government of India and other agencies for policy and program purposes; and secondly, to help in measuring the trends in the health and family welfare issues.
The interview schedules were used for data collection by trained investigators. The interviews were conducted with eligible respondents using a Household Questionnaire, a Woman's Questionnaire (for women aged 15-49) and a Man's Questionnaire (for men aged 15-54). Total 18 research organizations conducted interviews with more than 230,000 women (age 15-49 years) and men (age 15-54 years) throughout India. NFHS-3 also tested more than 100,000 women and men for HIV and more than 200,000 adults and young children for anemia.  The information and activities carried out can be clubbed as follows:
- Household interview: Interview with the household head or any adult household member. As a part of the household interview, cooking salt was also tested for iodine content.
- Individual respondent's interview
- Measurement of height, weight and hemoglobin content in the blood of interviewed women and men, as well as children born in January 2000 (January 2001 for the second round of interviewing) or later who were at least 6 months old, using the HemoCue instrument.
- Collection of blood samples on filter paper cards (Dried Blood Sample), using finger-prick method, from men aged 15-54 and women aged 15-49 years for HIV testing.
The NFHS-3 has collected information on several new and emerging issues (which were not covered in the previous round), including perinatal mortality, male involvement in family welfare, adolescent reproductive health, high-risk sexual behavior, family life, education, safe injections, tuberculosis and malaria. It also focused upon family welfare and health conditions among slum dwellers in eight large cities. For the first time ever, blood samples have been collected to know the HIV prevalence at the national level and in the five high-prevalence states. 
The methodology received ethical approval from the MOHFW and independent ethical approval committee of independent experts.  The blood sample collection for both HIV testing and hemoglobin estimation was standardized and collection was done after informed consent of the subjects as approved by the ethical committee. It was decided to keep the HIV testing as 'unlinked and anonymous' and the results of such testing were used for survey purpose only. The details of the procedure are available on IIPS website. 
The outputs of NFHS-3 have been planned in the form of state and national fact sheets, national report in two volumes, state reports, specialized subject reports, key findings report and wall charts. The states and India fact sheets are the first in the series of the findings to be released. These fact sheets provide information on fertility, family planning, age at marriage and first child birth; and maternal health indicators like three ANC visits, institutional deliveries, childhood immunization, health-seeking behavior, nutritional status and anemia, besides knowledge of adult population on HIV/AIDS and women empowerment.  The details of methodology can be found on the website of IIPS. 
This paper analyses the information available from the NFHS-3. Special attention has been given to the five empowered action group (EAG) states (Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Rajasthan and Orissa). The indicators of Kerala state and India have been provided for comparison. The EAG states have been identified for this review as they are known for poor performance on majority of the health indicators and constitute more than 40% of the total population of the country. No health goal is achievable unless the performance of these states is improved. Even the planning commission of India recognizes their special needs for planning and policy-making purpose. 
| ¤ Results of NFHS-3|| |
During the past 13 years, since the first NFHS, there has been continuous decline in fertility in India. Some states have reached the replacement level of fertility, viz., Kerala, Punjab and Maharashtra; while the total fertility rate (TFR) in states like UP and MP is very high - at 3.82 and 3.12 respectively. Bihar has been found to show a trend of increasing fertility too [Table - 1]. The decline in TFR is noticeable across the country although the progress is slow in the EAG states. The urban areas in majority of the states have either reached TFR of replacement level or are very close to doing so. The wide rural-urban difference is still continuing - viz., the TFR in urban Orissa has gone to a level below 2, while TFR in rural areas of UP is well above 4. ,,
The reproductive and child health (RCH) program recommends at least three visits to the ANC by pregnant women in India. Only one-fourth to one-third women while pregnant paid three or more ANC visits [Table - 2]. The only consolation is the increasing proportion of such women. The proportion of women who had taken IFA tablets for a stipulated period of more than 90 days during the last pregnancy is as low as 8.7% in UP. Only one-fourth deliveries in EAG states are institutional in comparison to Kerala, where this proportion is almost 100%. 
The infant mortality rate has decreased uniformly in the country [Table - 1]. The EAG states have shown noticeable improvement on this indicator. Orissa has achieved almost 40% reduction in IMR in the last 13 years. A number of states have reached the national goal of IMR, viz., 60%, and some other are approaching the goal. The NFHS-3 shows that the number of fully immunized children (children in the age group of 12-23 months who have received BCG, OPV - three doses; DPT - three doses; measles and vitamin A) is either constant at a low level or fallen (in Maharashtra, Punjab, Delhi). Although the proportion of such children has increased in EAG states, yet less than half of such children are fully immunized [Table - 2]. The coverage with vitamin A is abysmal, at 10-30%, throughout the country, and not even one-third of the children aged 9-36 months had received vitamin A in the last 6 months. The proportion was in single figure in UP. 
There is a fall in the proportion of the parents going to the health facility in cases of illness of their child since NFHS-2. The proportion of children who received ORS for the last episode of diarrhea has decreased in most of the states and ranges from 12-41%.
Nutrition and anemia
The nutritional status of children aged less than 3 years and women is shown in [Table - 3].
The overall proportion of undernourished children has increased in the country since NFHS-2; and in the states of MP, UP and Bihar, almost 85% of children were found to be anemic. As many as 74% of this population group are anemic in India, with prevalence of anemia in UP as high as 85.1%. What is more worrisome is the increasing prevalence of anemia since NFHS-2. This proportion is higher than both the previous rounds of NFHS. The total prevalence of wasting among children has also increased from 15% in NFHS-2 to 17% in this round. More than half to two-thirds of women, whether pregnant or not, are anemic. This prevalence has risen since NFHS-2; and in some cases, since NFHS-1 also. Anemia is not restricted to women and children only. Adult men are also commonly affected with the problem of anemia, and up to two-thirds of men are anemic, with uniform distribution. 
| ¤ Discussion|| |
The NFHS-3 data can very well be taken as an alarming bell. Increasing anemia, malnutrition and decreasing utilization of health services must be the signs of concern for the planners.
While the falling TFR and rising couple protection rate (CPR) are some signs of hope, the progress in EAG states is a bit slow but trends are favorable. The rural areas are still lagging far behind, and the planners need to think of targeted interventions in these states and areas, addressing issues like son preference, low rate of male sterilization, etc. Limited decision-making power to women is detrimental to fertility control as even a mother wants family planning, but she cannot decide for herself. The empowerment of women will be a health-improving measure.
The NFHS-3 findings show an inverse relationship between fertility and the educational status of the mother. When making a comparison between the fertility of women with no education and those with 10 or more years of education, a difference of two children is noticeable in majority of the states. 
Decreasing fertility may be attributable to increased CPR, increased age at marriage and increased age at the first child birth, as reported in NFHS-3. 
Smaller contribution of male sterilization, which is also falling ever since NFHS-1, is another area of concern. 
The Government of India started national nutritional anemia prophylaxis program in 1970  and ICDS in 1975.  Out of the many objectives of these programs, the main were to improve nutritional status and reduce anemia amongst children and women in the reproductive age group. Despite of these, low coverage with IFA and high prevalence of anemia in women and children are well-known issues. ,, Thousands of Anganwadi centers, subcenters, primary health centers and health facilities in urban area are involved in iron tablet distribution.  Why anemia is increasing and why coverage with IFA is low are questions that need to be answered. It seems that absence of focus of the program at the lowest level or shortage of iron tablets is also a familiar scenario at the ground level. The NFHS-3 findings should act as a trigger for independent evaluation of the program, with special focus on the qualitative aspects. Alternative strategies for distribution of IFA tablets are immediately needed. New researches should be the basis of interventions carried out to reduce the prevalence of anemia in this population. ,, Besides, measures like legislation, salt fortification or use of 'iron tablets'-vending machines in the country may also be tried for the fulfillment of this aim. The same measures should be clubbed with promotion of ORS for diarrhea.
The data on the nutritional status of children aged less than 3 years does not give a good picture. The schemes like ICDS and midday meal are being praised at many a places.  There seems to be almost no excuse for almost half of the children under the age of 3 years being undernourished. What is more worrying is that this proportion has increased since NFHS-2.
The absolute level of anemia has increased, and there are adverse trends in NFHS-3. Children (6-35 months) and pregnant women, the most vulnerable sections of our population, are suffering more and more in an era of economic growth of India. This high level of malnutrition increases the chances of getting infections and leading to high mortality levels, especially infant mortality and maternal mortality. Improved fertility indicators would be hollow if this same population continues to be anemic and malnourished.
The family planning program has been rechristened and redesigned many a times, but the main focus still seems to be 'fertility control.' Infants and children do not appear to get the desired attention, and the low rate of postpartum visits may be a dummy indicator. Immunization coverage in India has fallen, and the states which are most affected are EAG states.  Occasionally, researchers have attributed this to the repeated pulse polio activities also, but that cannot be a complete explanation.  The proportion of fully immunized children is less than half in majority of the states. Immunization activities in RCH program seem to be relegated as a secondary work. This component needs rethinking and restructuring after careful evaluation.
It is not that everything is bad with NFHS. It has some features that need to be mentioned, e.g., timely release of data. The timeliness in disseminating the results of national surveys is essential for planners and policy makers. Lengthy time lags between data collection and tabulation invariably make the data obsolete. The same pace should be there for taking corrective measures based upon these findings. Detailed information on a number of health indicators is a distinct advantage of NFHS over other surveys conducted in the country, viz., census, sample registration system. 
Secondly, the conducting of NFHSs by an independent agency, without any control of government, either in funding or in technical assistance, increases reliability and acceptability of the results. The NFHSs are laudable efforts only if the findings are used for corrective measures. The current trends in health indicators do not suggest that serious action is being taken to improve the health scenario or program in the country on the basis of NFHS findings. The whole exercise is futile if no corrective measures are taken. The NFHS findings need to be given more attention by both national and state governments for planning and resource allocations.
Finally, planning of such a massive survey is a Herculean task, but even such a big survey does not provide district-wise data (because the sample size does not permit generalizing at the district level); this is one great weakness. India's incredible diversity makes district data an absolute necessity to get at reality. At a time when decentralization has become a buzzword, state level data have limited value. The district level data may be useful for planning and also for monitoring and assessing the impact of numerous developmental programs at the local level. The Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare had started such useful district level surveys, initially called reproductive and child health (RCH) surveys and now called district level household surveys (DLHS), in the year 2002.  The data generated by these surveys are far more useful than NFHS data, but these are hardly discussed and used. The state-level data are good and give a large picture of the states. What is equally required is the district-level health information so that necessary action may be taken at the right place. The DLHS should be done in the inter-NFHS period to make NFHS data more useful. These surveys can be a difficult and massive exercise. Initially, this exercise may be restricted to poorly performing states as per NFHS.
| ¤ Triggers from NFHS-3|| |
- Malnutrition and anemia are two major health problems in the country. Fourteen years have elapsed since the National Nutrition Policy  was formed, but the specific targets of this policy have definitely not been met and the scenario is the same as it was then. The National Health Policy  still does not have any indicators on anemia. It is not that both the policies should have indicators on anemia and nutrition, but it is about having a mechanism for achieving a common goal through coordination, which does not seem to exist.
- The Anganwadi centers functioning under ICDS project may need to be restructured, along with availing the services of ASHA under NRHM,  to provide services for nutrition of women and children, IFA and iron supplementation, vitamin A prophylaxis and ORS and condom distribution. The supplementation may be replaced by one complete meal for all children under the age of 6 years at AW centers.
- It can be clearly seen that some states where midday meal program is working properly, e.g., Tamil Nadu, have shown significant improvement in the health status of children.  The handing over of this program to private organizations, NGOs in some districts of Rajasthan, UP has also produced good results. These cases should immediately be studied in details and may be utilized for needful modification in the functioning of this program.
- The proportion of fully immunized children of mothers who had 10 or more years of education was almost double the proportion of children of illiterate mothers. Similarly, educated women had one child less than their illiterate counterparts. In simple terms, education of women is directly related to the fertility pattern and also to other child-health indicators, as we notice in NFHS-3. The investment in the education of a girl child should be considered an investment in the health sector.
- The timing of NFHS-3 is very appropriate as the findings of this round, if released timely, can be utilized in the implementation of the national rural health mission in the country. 
- Maintaining the health status of the population needs multi-sectorial coordination. The NFHS may be a good tool for evaluation. The responsibility to conduct NFHS can be entrusted with the Planning Commission as probably the NFHS data may be better utilized for rational allocation of resources to the states by the planning commission. This would also help the planning commission to monitor and regulate health-related interventions and programs of the central and state governments.
- There is need for revival of the DLHS as these may prove more useful, as described earlier.
| ¤ Conclusions|| |
This review suggests that NFHS is a good exercise, which generates data to be utilized for planning, monitoring, evaluation and resource allocation to various programs in India. The findings of NFHS-3 point out that there has been almost no improvement in the health status of women and children in India for the last 15 years, and in some cases their condition has even deteriorated. The most probable reason is that the results of these successive surveys are not being utilized for the stated objective of taking corrective measures in the programs. The NFHS-3 should act as a trigger for a new beginning. The immediate focus of the country should be on improvement of health status of women and children; immunization strengthening; increased access to basic medicines like iron tablets, and ORS and health facilities for the poor people. At a time when one of the most ambitious programs on health, NRHM, is being rolled out, it is very pertinent that these findings are used for decision making. Besides, the DLHS should be made routine exercise during the inter-NFHS period. The idea of Planning Commission using the findings of NFHS-3 for resource allocation also needs immediate attention. These efforts should bring about some positive changes in the health status of this population; and who knows, we may achieve what have been elusive health goals for many years when India conducts the next round of NFHS, somewhere in 2012 or 2013.
| ¤ References|| |
|1.||International Institute of Population Sciences and ORC Macro. National Family Health Survey - 3. International Institute of Population Sciences, Mumbai. [Last accessed on 2007 Apr 5]. Available from: http://www.iipsindia.org/nfhs3.html. |
|2.||International Institute of Population Sciences and ORC Macro. National Family Health Survey-2. National report. International Institute of Population Sciences: Mumbai; 2000. p. 015-248. |
|3.||International Institute of Population Sciences. State fact sheets of NFHS-3. IIPS and Macro ORC. 2006. [Last accessed on 2007 Apr 9]. Available from: http://www.iipsindia.org/factsheets.html. |
|4.||Government of India. Toward a faster growth: 10 th Plan (2007-12) draft. The Planning Commission: New Delhi; 2002. p. 55-74. |
|5.||Government of India. Manual of Reproductive and Child health-2. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. Nirman Bhawan: New Delhi; 2005. p. 001-148. |
|6.||Sharma RS, Rajalakshmi M, Sharma Rs, Jeyaraj DA. Current status of fertility control methods in India. J Biosci 2001;26:391-405. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT]|
|7.||Government of India. Annual report 2005-06. Ministry of Health and Family welfare. Nirman Bhawan: New Delhi; 2006. p. 01-77. |
|8.||Government of India. Integrated Child Development Scheme Manual, New Delhi; 1992. p. 011-45. |
|9.||Toteja GS, Singh P, Dhillon BS, Saxena BN, Ahmed FU, Singh RP, et al . Prevalence of anemia amongst pregnant women and adolescent girls in 16 districts of India. Food Nutr Bull 2006;27:311-5. [PUBMED] |
|10.||Singh MB, Fotedar R, Lakshminarayan J, Anand PK. Studies on the nutritional status of children aged 0-5 years in a drought affected desert area of western Rajasthan, India. Public Health Nutr 2006;9:961-7. |
|11.||Pathak P, Kapil U, Kapoor SK, Saxena R, Kumar A, Gupta N, et al . Prevalence of multiple micronutrient deficiency amongst pregnant women in rural area of Haryana. Indian J Pediatr 2004;71:1007-14. |
|12.||Zlotkins HS, Christofides AL, Hyder SM, Schauer CS, Tondeur MC, Sharieff W. Controlling iron deficiency anemia through home fortified complementary food. Indian J Pediatr 2004;71:315-9. |
|13.||Agarwal KN, Gomber S, Bishh, Som M. Anemia prophylaxis in adolescent school girls by weekly or daily iron folate supplementation. Indian Pediatr 2003;40:296-301. |
|14.||Afridi F. Mid Day meal in two states: Comparing the financial and institutional organisation of the program. Econ Polit Wkly 2005;15:1528-35. |
|15.||Childhood lost: A special report on NFHS-3. Times of India: New Delhi; Dec 19, 2006. p. 12. |
|16.||Datar A, Mukherjee A, Sood N. Health infrastructure and immunisation coverage in rural India. Indian J Med Res 2007;125:31-42. |
|17.||Lodha R, Das NR, Kapil A, Kabra SK. Diphtheria in urban slums in India. Lancet 2000;355:204. |
|18.||Government of India. Sample Registration System bulletin, Registrar General of India, New Delhi; April 2006. p. 1-7. |
|19.||Government of India. District Level Health Surveys 2002-2004, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, New Delhi, 2005. [Last accessed on 2007 Jan 23]. Available from: http://www.mohfw.nic.in. |
|20.||Government of India. National Nutrition Policy, Ministry of women and Child development, GOI, New Delhi; 1993. p. 01-23. Available from: http://www.wcd.nic.in/nnp.pdf. |
|21.||Government of India. The National Health Policy 2002. Ministry of Health and Family welfare, Nirman Bhawan: New Delhi; 2002. p. 01-39. |
|22.||Government of India. National Rural Health Mission. Ministry of health and family welfare, Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi. 2006. [Last accessed on 2006 Dec 16]. Available from: http://www.mohfw.nic.in/nrhm. |
[Table - 1], [Table - 2], [Table - 3]
|This article has been cited by|
||Efficiency of red cell distribution width in identification of children aged 1-3 years with iron deficiency anemia against traditional hematological markers
| ||Sunil Sazawal,Usha Dhingra,Pratibha Dhingra,Arup Dutta,Hiba Shabir,Venugopal P Menon,Robert E Black |
| ||BMC Pediatrics. 2014; 14(1): 8 |
||Inadequate feeding of infant and young children in India: lack of nutritional information or food affordability?
| ||Nisha Malhotra |
| ||Public Health Nutrition. 2013; 16(10): 1723 |
||National Rural Health Mission
| ||Bhavna Dhingra, Ashok Kumar Dutta |
| ||The Indian Journal of Pediatrics. 2011; |
||Burden, Differentials, and Causes of Child Deaths in India
| ||Chandrakant Lahariya, Vinod K. Paul |
| ||The Indian Journal of Pediatrics. 2010; 77(11): 1312 |
||Causes of Child Deaths in India, 1985–2008: A Systematic Review of Literature
| ||Chandrakant Lahariya, Christopher R. Sudfeld, Deepankar Lahariya, Shailendra S. Tomar |
| ||The Indian Journal of Pediatrics. 2010; 77(11): 1303 |
||Breastfeeding and complementary feeding as a public health intervention for child survival in India
| ||Arun Gupta, J. P. Dadhich, M. M. A. Faridi |
| ||The Indian Journal of Pediatrics. 2010; 77(4): 413 |
||Primary health care and child survival in India
| ||Chandrakant Lahariya, Rajesh Khanna, Deoki Nandan |
| ||The Indian Journal of Pediatrics. 2010; 77(3): 283 |
||Nutrition and child survival in India
| ||Prema Ramachandran |
| ||The Indian Journal of Pediatrics. 2010; 77(3): 301 |
||Micronutrient supplementation and child survival in India
| ||Prakash V. Kotecha, Chandrakant Lahariya |
| ||The Indian Journal of Pediatrics. 2010; 77(4): 419 |